Which Mob Boss Are You?

Which Mob Boss Could You Be?

The American Mafia produced some of the most distinctive and powerful personalities in criminal history. Each boss had a completely different approach to leadership — and the results of our quiz reflect five fundamentally different styles of power. Here is what each result means.

Lucky Luciano — The Strategic Genius

If you get Lucky Luciano you are the most dangerous kind of leader: one who wins without anyone realising you were playing. Luciano ended the Castellammarese War in 1931 by engineering the murders of both rival bosses, then immediately abolished the title of Boss of Bosses and replaced it with the Commission — a governing body that made conflict less likely and profit more certain. He was deported to Italy in 1946 but continued directing American operations from overseas. His peak net worth is estimated at $200 million in 1930s dollars — equivalent to roughly $3.5 billion today.

Al Capone — The Force of Nature

If you get Al Capone you lead through sheer force of personality — bold, fearless and impossible to ignore. Capone built a criminal empire worth $60 million a year during Prohibition, controlled Chicago through bribery and violence, and became the most famous gangster in American history. He was brought down not by murder charges but by the IRS — convicted of tax evasion in 1931 and sentenced to eleven years. His downfall came from the one thing he never thought to guard against: paperwork.

John Gotti — The Dapper Don

If you get John Gotti you understand that power is also a performance. Gotti wore $1,800 suits, held court outside his Queens social club for press photographers, and became the most famous Mafia boss in America by being impossible to ignore. He beat three federal prosecutions — earning the nickname the Teflon Don — before his underboss Sammy Gravano turned government witness in 1991. Gotti was convicted on all counts in 1992 and died in prison in 2002. His legacy is both magnificent and cautionary.

Carlo Gambino — The Shadow King

If you get Carlo Gambino you are the most dangerous result of all — because nobody sees you coming. Gambino led the most powerful crime family in America from 1957 until his natural death in 1976 without ever spending a significant period in prison. He never appeared in newspapers if he could help it. He never made speeches or held court for photographers. He simply accumulated power, quietly and relentlessly, until there was no one above him. His peak net worth is estimated at $400 million — equivalent to roughly $4 billion today.

Albert Anastasia — The Lord High Executioner

If you get Albert Anastasia you believe in decisive action and absolute loyalty. Anastasia founded Murder Incorporated — the enforcement arm of the American Mafia that carried out between 400 and 1,000 contract killings between 1929 and 1941. He rose to become boss of the Gambino family through conspiracy and intimidation. He was shot dead in a Manhattan barbershop in October 1957, killed by men sent by his own underboss Carlo Gambino. Even the most feared men in the room are not safe from the quiet ones.

About This Quiz

This quiz uses a personality scoring system based on four questions covering leadership style, conflict resolution, public profile and personal conduct. Your answers are matched to the mob boss whose historical personality and leadership approach most closely reflects your own instincts. There are five possible results — Lucky Luciano, Al Capone, John Gotti, Carlo Gambino and Albert Anastasia — each representing a fundamentally different style of power.

Enter your name and email at the end to see your result and join the NCS Inner Circle — our weekly mob history newsletter delivering one story per week direct to your inbox.