Top 5 Most Feared Mobsters of All Time

Power in the Mafia was always enforced by violence — or the credible threat of it. But even within that world, certain figures stood apart. Men who were feared not just by their enemies but by their own allies. Men whose names, spoken in the wrong room, could end a conversation. These are the five most feared mobsters in the history of American organised crime.

1. Albert Anastasia — The Lord High Executioner

If there is one figure in American Mafia history whose name made other gangsters genuinely afraid, it is Albert Anastasia. Born in Calabria, Italy in 1902, Anastasia came to America as a teenager and found his natural environment in the violence of Brooklyn’s waterfront gangs. By the time he was in his twenties he had already killed multiple men and was a force that even senior figures gave a wide berth to.

Anastasia became the operational head of Murder Incorporated — the enforcement arm of the national crime syndicate that carried out contract killings across the country throughout the 1930s. He ran it with a volatility that terrified even his own men. Unlike other Murder Inc figures who were professional and businesslike about killing, Anastasia was capable of ordering murders on impulse — reportedly ordering a hit on a man he saw on television simply because the man had been a witness in a robbery and Anastasia felt he shouldn’t have cooperated with police.

After the mysterious disappearance of Vincent Mangano in 1951 — widely believed to have been ordered by Anastasia himself — he took over what would become the Gambino crime family. He ran it through fear. Even Carlo Gambino, who would eventually orchestrate his removal, worked with extreme caution against him.

On 25 October 1957, Anastasia was shot dead in the barbershop of the Park Sheraton Hotel in Midtown Manhattan. His bodyguard had conveniently taken a walk. Two gunmen entered, opened fire, and fled. Anastasia charged at them but in the confusion attacked their reflections in the mirror rather than the men themselves. He was 55 years old.

Even in death, no one was ever charged with his murder.

2. Roy DeMeo — The Gemini Method

Roy DeMeo didn’t look like a monster. He was a chubby, jovial Gambino family associate from Canarsie, Brooklyn who owned a car dealership and seemed, to outsiders, like a reasonably successful small businessman. What he was running from the back room of the Gemini Lounge on Flatlands Avenue was something else entirely.

DeMeo and his crew — particularly Anthony Senter and Joseph Testa, known as the Gemini Twins — developed what investigators came to call the Gemini Method. A victim would be lured to an apartment above the lounge. One crew member would shoot them in the head with a silenced weapon. Another would immediately wrap a towel around the wound to minimise blood spray. The body was then carried to the bathroom where it was hung over the tub, the jugular cut to drain the blood. The body was then dismembered and the parts distributed across multiple disposal sites.

The system was efficient, thorough and almost impossible to forensically reconstruct. DeMeo’s crew is believed to have killed between 75 and 200 people — the uncertainty itself a measure of how effective their methods were at making victims simply disappear.

Even within the Gambino family, DeMeo was considered dangerous in a way that made people uncomfortable. He was too indiscriminate, too willing to kill without sanction. When the FBI began closing in in the early 1980s, his own family decided he was a liability. In January 1983, Roy DeMeo was found shot dead in the boot of his car in a Brooklyn parking lot. He was 42 years old.

3. Carmine Galante — The Man Who Threatened the Commission

Most mob bosses understood that the Commission existed to prevent exactly the kind of unchecked ambition that had made the Prohibition era so bloody. Carmine Galante either didn’t understand this or didn’t care.

Galante — known as Lilo, always photographed with a cigar — had spent eleven years in prison on a narcotics conviction and emerged in 1974 with his ambitions undimmed and his patience exhausted. He took effective control of the Bonanno family and immediately set about building the most profitable heroin import operation in American history, using connections in Sicily that bypassed the Commission’s nominal ban on narcotics dealing.

He brought in Sicilian Mafia members — the Zips, as American mobsters called them — as his personal bodyguards and enforcers. He openly told associates that he intended to become Boss of All Bosses. He made clear he considered the other Commission families beneath him.

This was not a sustainable position. The Commission — the bosses of the other four families — sanctioned his murder in the summer of 1979. On 12 July 1979, three masked gunmen walked onto the outdoor patio of Joe and Mary’s restaurant in Bushwick, Brooklyn and opened fire. Galante and two companions were killed. His two Sicilian bodyguards walked away without a scratch — almost certainly having been party to the hit.

He was found face down with an eye shot out and the cigar still clenched in his teeth. The photograph became one of the most iconic images in mob history.

4. Vito Genovese — The Boss Who Feared No One

What made Vito Genovese genuinely frightening was not the scale of his violence — other bosses killed more people — but his willingness to target men who should have been untouchable. He ordered the murder of Ferdinand “The Shadow” Boccia in 1934 while Boccia was under the protection of Lucky Luciano. He ordered the 1957 assassination attempt on Frank Costello — the Prime Minister of the Underworld, one of the most connected and protected men in American organised crime. He orchestrated the murder of Albert Anastasia the same year.

Genovese operated without the diplomatic instincts that made bosses like Costello and Carlo Gambino so effective. He was confrontational, aggressive and deeply suspicious — even paranoid. He trusted almost no one and was right to distrust most of them.

In 1937, facing a murder charge, he fled to Italy where he became a personal acquaintance of Mussolini, financing Fascist operations while continuing to run narcotics smuggling routes back to the United States. He returned to America after the war, had the key witness against him murdered, and resumed his criminal career as if nothing had happened.

He was finally convicted on narcotics charges in 1959 and sentenced to fifteen years. He died in prison in 1969. Even from his cell, he continued to issue orders and was believed to have sanctioned murders during his imprisonment.

5. Harry “Pittsburgh Phil” Strauss — Murder Inc’s Most Prolific Killer

Harry Strauss was the most prolific contract killer in the history of American organised crime. A member of Murder Incorporated’s Brownsville crew, Pittsburgh Phil — as he was known — is believed to have personally carried out over 100 murders during his career, making him by any measure the deadliest hitman the American Mafia ever produced.

What distinguished Strauss was not just the volume of his work but his professionalism and his apparent enthusiasm for it. He travelled across the country to carry out assignments, killing in multiple states — which made him particularly difficult to prosecute, as he had no connection to his victims in the jurisdictions where the murders occurred. He used a variety of methods: guns, ice picks, garrotes, whatever the circumstances required.

Fellow Murder Inc member Abe Reles described Strauss as someone who genuinely enjoyed his work — who approached killing with something closer to excitement than the businesslike neutrality most hitmen cultivated. This made him invaluable to the organisation and terrifying to anyone who crossed the people who employed him.

Strauss’s downfall came when Reles turned government witness in 1940, providing testimony about dozens of Murder Inc killings. Strauss was convicted of murder and sentenced to death. He was executed in the electric chair at Sing Sing Prison on 12 June 1941, at the age of 33 — the same day as his Murder Inc associate Happy Maione.

Frequently Asked Questions