Phil Leonetti: The Philadelphia Underboss Who Turned Witness
Philip “Phil” Leonetti was the underboss of the Philadelphia crime family in the 1980s and the nephew of its boss, Nicodemo “Little Nicky” Scarfo. He was made underboss in January 1986, at 32, which made him one of the youngest underbosses in the modern American Mafia. In November 1988 he was convicted with his uncle and other members of the family in a federal racketeering case, and in May 1989 he was sentenced to 45 years in prison.
He then did what almost no one of his rank had done before: he agreed to co-operate with the government. He admitted taking part in ten murders and testified in a series of federal and state trials against the Philadelphia family and others. A judge later called him “the most significant crime figure who chose to co-operate”, and his sentence was cut to the time he had served. Because he is living, this article sticks to his convictions, the court record and his sworn testimony.

Quick facts
| Born | 27 March 1953, Philadelphia |
| Uncle | Nicodemo “Little Nicky” Scarfo, boss of the Philadelphia family from the early 1980s |
| Base | Atlantic City, New Jersey |
| Rank | Made member June 1980; captain 1981; underboss January 1986, according to New Jersey’s State Commission of Investigation |
| Convicted | November 1988, federal racketeering (RICO), Eastern District of Pennsylvania |
| Sentence | 45 years (May 1989); reduced in 1992 |
| Co-operation | Began in 1989; testified in eight federal trials, three retrials and three state trials, according to the Commission |
| Admitted | Taking part in ten murders |
| Released | After about five and a half years in custody; entered the federal Witness Security Program |

The Ravenite escape room
247 Mulberry Street, December 1989. The FBI hit the building next. Walk the scene in 3D, read the real evidence and crack the padlock before the clock runs out.
Play free in your browser →No download. Works on phone and desktop.or get the app: App Store · Google PlayBorn into it
Leonetti was born in Philadelphia on 27 March 1953. His mother, Annunziata “Nancy” Scarfo, was the sister of Nicodemo Scarfo, and both sides of the family had links to the Mafia. His father, Pasquale Leonetti, had been given charge of card and dice games in South Philadelphia under the then boss, Angelo Bruno.
As a child Leonetti moved with his mother to the Ducktown neighbourhood of Atlantic City, where Scarfo was based, and his uncle took a close interest in him from his schooldays. He was a talented basketball player at Holy Spirit High School in Absecon, New Jersey, but Scarfo had other plans for him. Atlantic City was about to change: casino gambling was legalised there in the late 1970s, and the mob saw the construction work and unions that came with it as a huge opportunity (see from the mob to regulation: the story of casino gambling).
The Falcone killing, 1979
In December 1979 Vincent Falcone, an associate of Scarfo’s crew, was shot dead in New Jersey. In the later federal racketeering case the killing was charged as one of the racketeering acts against both Scarfo and Leonetti, and a witness testified at trial that Leonetti fired the shots. Leonetti himself later admitted the killing as part of his co-operation. We say what happened and move on; for how such killings fitted the mob’s rules, see our list of famous mob hits.
Rising under Scarfo
Philadelphia’s long-serving boss Angelo Bruno was murdered in March 1980, and the family was thrown into a period of killings and power struggles. By 1981 Scarfo had emerged as boss. His reign was the bloodiest in the family’s history: in the 1988 federal case, prosecutors charged a racketeering conspiracy involving 13 murders.
Leonetti rose with his uncle. According to New Jersey’s State Commission of Investigation, he became a made member in June 1980, a captain in 1981 and underboss in January 1986. For what each of those ranks means, see how a Mafia family is structured. The press called him “Crazy Phil”, a name he has said came from a local radio host.
Trials and acquittals
Leonetti was charged in several cases in the late 1980s. In November 1986 he was indicted on New Jersey state racketeering conspiracy charges. In December 1987 he was acquitted of federal drug charges, and in May 1988, according to the Mob Museum, he and Scarfo were acquitted of the 1984 murder of Salvatore Testa, a young captain in the family.
The case that brought him down was federal. In November 1988, after a ten-week trial in the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, Scarfo, Leonetti and more than a dozen co-defendants were convicted of racketeering. The evidence covered murders, extortion, loansharking, illegal bookmaking and drug dealing. In May 1989 Scarfo was sentenced to 55 years and Leonetti to 45.
The witness
Facing what was effectively a life sentence, Leonetti began co-operating with federal investigators in 1989. He broke the Mafia’s code of silence, omertà (see our ultimate Mafia glossary), and admitted taking part in ten murders. New Jersey’s State Commission of Investigation described him as the highest-ranking member of the Philadelphia and South Jersey family ever to co-operate against La Cosa Nostra.

According to the Commission, he went on to testify in eight federal trials, three retrials and three state trials involving several Mafia families, and his evidence contributed to the convictions of more than 15 made members and 23 associates. He also gave a sworn declaration in a 1990 civil racketeering case over Local 54 of the hotel and restaurant workers’ union in Atlantic City, which led to a court-ordered takeover of the union, and the Commission said information he provided contributed to the 1993 federal indictment of Genovese boss Vincent Gigante.
He was not the first made man to break the code in public; that distinction is usually given to Joe Valachi in 1963. But he was one of the highest-ranking, and he came just before Sammy Gravano, the Gambino underboss whose testimony convicted John Gotti in 1992.
Sentence cut and release
In May 1992, when Leonetti was resentenced, the court described his co-operation as “extraordinary” and called him “the most significant crime figure who chose to co-operate”. His 45-year sentence was reduced. He served about five and a half years in custody in total (several accounts give it as five years, five months and five days) and then entered the federal Witness Security Program.
Later life
Leonetti has lived under an assumed name since his release. In 2012 the Philadelphia Inquirer reported that he was living in a seaside community on the West Coast with his wife. He has said that a price was put on his head after he turned. He has told his own story in a memoir, Mafia Prince, and in interviews; where this article relies on his own account rather than the court record, we say so.
His uncle, Nicky Scarfo, never co-operated. He died in federal custody in January 2017, aged 87.
Why he matters
Leonetti’s decision showed that the ties of blood the Mafia relied on could break. If the boss’s own nephew and underboss would testify, nobody’s loyalty could be taken for granted. His evidence helped dismantle the Scarfo-era leadership of the Philadelphia family and fed into cases in New York, at the start of a decade in which the American Mafia lost more of its leaders to informers than ever before.
If you want to step into the world of the American mob, try our Five Families escape rooms.
Related reading: Sammy Gravano · Joe Valachi and the McClellan hearings · How a Mafia family is structured · Casino gambling: from the mob to regulation
FAQs
Who is Phil Leonetti?
Philip Leonetti is the former underboss of the Philadelphia crime family and the nephew of its boss, Nicodemo Scarfo. He was convicted of racketeering in 1988 and later became a government witness.
What was Phil Leonetti convicted of?
He was convicted of federal racketeering (RICO) charges in November 1988 alongside Scarfo and other members of the family, and was sentenced to 45 years in May 1989.
How long did Phil Leonetti serve in prison?
About five and a half years. His sentence was reduced in 1992 because of his co-operation with prosecutors.
How many murders did Phil Leonetti admit?
As part of his co-operation he admitted taking part in ten murders.
Who did Phil Leonetti testify against?
According to New Jersey’s State Commission of Investigation, he testified in eight federal trials, three retrials and three state trials involving several Mafia families, including the Philadelphia family he had helped lead.
Was Phil Leonetti related to Nicky Scarfo?
Yes. Scarfo was his uncle, his mother’s brother.
Where is Phil Leonetti now?
He has lived under an assumed name since leaving prison. His exact whereabouts are not public.






