On This Day in 1991 the Third Colombo War Erupted
On 18 November 1991, gunmen loyal to acting Colombo boss Victor Orena ambushed Gregory Scarpa Sr. on a street in Brooklyn. Scarpa, the most feared enforcer in the faction loyal to jailed boss Carmine Persico, was driving with family members close by when two cars blocked him in. The hitmen opened fire. Scarpa escaped by ramming his way out. The failed hit turned a simmering leadership dispute into the Third Colombo War.
The full story: Joe Colombo: The Mobster Who Started a Civil Rights Movement
A family divided
Carmine Persico had been the Colombo boss since the 1970s, but by 1991 he was serving a 100-year sentence from the Commission Trial. He wanted the family run on his behalf until his son Alphonse could take over. Victor Orena, the acting boss, had other ideas and tried to win support to take the top job for himself.
In June 1991, a Persico hit team lay in wait near Orena’s home on Long Island. Orena spotted the gunmen and escaped. He decided to strike back, and Scarpa was the obvious target.

Every date like this one, on your wall
A real photograph of a different boss every month, his rap sheet and the true story, with the anniversaries of famous hits and arrests marked on the grid. Printed to order near you. A gift for the mob-history fan in your life.
See the calendar →Or buy it now: A4 on Etsy · US Letter on Etsy · A4 on eBay UK, with UK delivery from eBay.Christmas cards, framed prints and printable mugshots are in the NCS store.The ambush
When the attackers converged on Scarpa’s car, he accelerated away, smashing into whatever was in his path. Several bystanders were hurt, but Scarpa and his relatives escaped without injury. Five days later, Henry “Hank the Bank” Smurra, a Persico loyalist, was shot dead outside a Brooklyn doughnut shop. From then on the factions hunted each other through the streets of Brooklyn and Long Island.
The cost
Scarpa became the Persico side’s chief killer. Yet he was hiding a secret: he had been an FBI informant on and off since the 1960s, something not made public until after his death in 1994.
The war left 12 people dead and many more wounded, including innocent bystanders. Prosecutors used the violence to charge dozens of mobsters. On 22 December 1992, Orena was convicted of racketeering and murder and later received three life sentences plus 85 years. By late 1992 the shooting had largely stopped, with Persico still in control.
Quick facts
- Date: 18 November 1991
- Place: Brooklyn, New York
- Target: Gregory Scarpa Sr., Persico faction enforcer
- Sides: Carmine Persico loyalists against Victor Orena
- Death toll: 12 killed during the war
- Outcome: Orena convicted in 1992, Persico kept control
More On This Day in Mob History
Further Reading — Mob History
Go deeper into the stories behind the dates. These are the essential books on organised crime history.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
More from National Crime Syndicate
Read the full story: The Colombo Crime Family






