On This Day in 1936 Lucky Luciano was Arraigned in New York
On 18 April 1936, Charles “Lucky” Luciano arrived back in New York under heavy police guard after losing his fight against extradition from Arkansas. Brought before Justice Philip J. McCook, he was jailed when the judge set bail at $350,000, an enormous sum at the time. The next morning’s New York Times ran the story on its front page. Some accounts, including Wikipedia, date the arraignment to the following day, 19 April.
Full profile: Lucky Luciano: Biography of the Man Who Built the American Mafia
Hiding in Hot Springs
Special prosecutor Thomas E. Dewey had spent months building a case that Luciano controlled organised prostitution in New York. Tipped off that witnesses were talking, Luciano left the city and turned up in Hot Springs, Arkansas, a spa town long friendly to gangsters.
A New York detective spotted him there and he was arrested on 1 April 1936. Released on a low bail, he was quickly rearrested on a fugitive warrant issued by Arkansas Attorney General Carl E. Bailey, who sent state troopers to move him to Little Rock. Luciano’s lawyers fought extradition, and Bailey publicly reported that he had been offered a bribe to help. It did not work.

Every date like this one, on your wall
A real photograph of a different boss every month, his rap sheet and the true story, with the anniversaries of famous hits and arrests marked on the grid. Printed to order near you. A gift for the mob-history fan in your life.
See the calendar →Or buy it now: A4 on Etsy · US Letter on Etsy · A4 on eBay UK, with UK delivery from eBay.Christmas cards, framed prints and printable mugshots are in the NCS store.The return
On 17 April Arkansas handed Luciano to New York detectives, and the party reached the city the next day. He was photographed arriving at police headquarters and questioned before his court appearance. In court, Dewey stressed the scale of Luciano’s income, and McCook set bail far beyond anything he could be expected to post. Luciano went to jail to await trial.
What came next
The trial began on 11 May 1936. On 7 June Luciano and his co-defendants were convicted of compulsory prostitution, and on 18 June he was sentenced to 30 to 50 years in state prison. It was one of the longest sentences ever handed down for the offence.
Luciano served about a decade before his sentence was commuted after the Second World War, on condition that he was deported to Italy. He never lived in America again.
Quick facts
- Date: 18 April 1936 (some sources say 19 April)
- Judge: Justice Philip J. McCook
- Bail: $350,000
- Prosecutor: Special prosecutor Thomas E. Dewey
- Arrested: Hot Springs, Arkansas, 1 April 1936
- Sentence: 30 to 50 years, handed down on 18 June 1936
Read more
Full story: Lucky Luciano: Biography of the Man Who Built the American Mafia.
More On This Day in Mob History
Further Reading — Mob History
Go deeper into the stories behind the dates. These are the essential books on organised crime history.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

