On This Day in 1931 Legs Diamond was Acquitted
On 17 December 1931, Jack “Legs” Diamond was acquitted of kidnapping by a jury in Troy, New York. He spent the evening celebrating in Albany. A few hours later, in the early morning of 18 December, two gunmen entered his room at a lodging house on Dove Street and shot him dead as he slept. The man who had survived so many attempts on his life did not survive his own victory party.
Who he was
Born in Philadelphia on 10 July 1897, Diamond made his name in New York as a bootlegger, hijacker and nightclub owner during Prohibition. He worked for and alongside figures such as Arnold Rothstein and fought bitter battles with rivals including Dutch Schultz. His nickname may have come from his skill as a dancer or from how quickly he could get away from his enemies.
He was shot so many times and survived that he became known as the “clay pigeon of the underworld.” Schultz reportedly complained in 1930: “Ain’t there nobody that can shoot this guy so he don’t bounce back?”

Every date like this one, on your wall
A real photograph of a different boss every month, his rap sheet and the true story, with the anniversaries of famous hits and arrests marked on the grid. Printed to order near you. A gift for the mob-history fan in your life.
See the calendar →Or buy it now: A4 on Etsy · US Letter on Etsy · A4 on eBay UK, with UK delivery from eBay.Christmas cards, framed prints and printable mugshots are in the NCS store.What happened
By 1931 Diamond had moved much of his operation to upstate New York. After his acquittal in Troy, he celebrated with family and friends at an Albany restaurant, then moved on to the Rain-Bo Room of the Kenmore Hotel on North Pearl Street with his mistress, the showgirl Marion “Kiki” Roberts.
At around 4:30 a.m. on 18 December, Diamond returned to his rooming house at 67 Dove Street and fell into a drunken sleep. About an hour later two men entered his room. One held him down while the other fired three shots into his head at close range.
Why it mattered
No one was charged. Suspects included Dutch Schultz and his men, among them Abraham “Bo” Weinberg. The Mob Museum notes that Diamond’s former partners Salvatore Spitale and Irving Bitz were also suspected, possibly over a failed narcotics deal. Decades later, author William Kennedy reported that Albany Democratic boss Dan O’Connell had claimed the killing was carried out by local police officers, led by Sergeant William Fitzpatrick, to stop New York City gangsters muscling in on the city.
Diamond’s widow, Alice, was found shot dead in her Brooklyn apartment on 1 July 1933. Her killing was never solved either.
Quick facts
- Acquitted: 17 December 1931, Troy, New York
- Killed: Early morning of 18 December 1931
- Place: 67 Dove Street, Albany, New York
- Victim: Jack “Legs” Diamond, Prohibition bootlegger
- Suspects: Dutch Schultz’s men, rival gangsters or Albany police
- Outcome: No one charged
More On This Day in Mob History
Further Reading — Mob History
Go deeper into the stories behind the dates. These are the essential books on organised crime history.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.






