On This Day in 1909 Joe Petrosino was Murdered in Palermo
On the evening of 12 March 1909, Lieutenant Joseph Petrosino of the New York Police Department was shot dead in the Piazza Marina in Palermo, Sicily. The famous detective had travelled to Italy on a secret mission to gather evidence against Italian criminals living in America. His murder shocked New York and remains unsolved in law.
Who he was
Born on 30 August 1860 in Padula, near Salerno, Petrosino emigrated to New York as a boy. He joined the NYPD in 1883 and became one of its best-known detectives at a time when the force had very few Italian-speaking officers. He specialised in the Black Hand extortion gangs that preyed on Italian immigrants, and in December 1908 he was promoted to lieutenant and given command of the department’s Italian Squad.

Every date like this one, on your wall
A real photograph of a different boss every month, his rap sheet and the true story, with the anniversaries of famous hits and arrests marked on the grid. Printed to order near you. A gift for the mob-history fan in your life.
See the calendar →Or buy it now: A4 on Etsy · US Letter on Etsy · A4 on eBay UK, with UK delivery from eBay.Christmas cards, framed prints and printable mugshots are in the NCS store.What happened
In early 1909 Petrosino sailed for Italy. Under a new federal law, immigrants with criminal records who had lied their way into the United States could be deported, and Petrosino’s job was to collect Italian police records that would prove it.
The mission was supposed to be secret, but it did not stay that way. Police Commissioner Theodore Bingham made comments to the press, and word spread that Petrosino was heading to Sicily. The US ambassador warned that he would be recognised there by perhaps a thousand criminals.
On the night of 12 March, while waiting in the Piazza Marina, Petrosino was attacked by two gunmen and shot at close range. He died at the scene.
Why it mattered
Suspicion fell on Vito Cascio Ferro, a powerful Sicilian Mafia figure whom Petrosino had once arrested in New York. Cascio Ferro was detained but released after an associate gave him an alibi. Historian Mike Dash has named Carlo Costantino and Antonio Passananti as likely gunmen, and a 2014 Italian investigation pointed to a Mafioso named Paolo Palazzotto. No one was ever convicted.
What came next
Petrosino’s body was shipped back to New York. On 12 April 1909 more than 200,000 people lined the streets for his funeral procession, and the city declared the day a public holiday. He is still honoured by the NYPD, and a small square in Lower Manhattan is named after him.
Quick facts
- Date: 12 March 1909
- Place: Piazza Marina, Palermo, Sicily
- Victim: Lieutenant Joseph Petrosino, NYPD Italian Squad
- Mission: Gathering criminal records to deport Italian criminals from the US
- Chief suspect: Vito Cascio Ferro, never convicted
- Funeral: More than 200,000 attended in New York on 12 April 1909
Read more
Full story: Who Was Joe Petrosino?.
Further Reading
Want to know more about This Mobster? Five Families is essential reading.
As an Amazon Associate, National Crime Syndicate earns from qualifying purchases.
More Mob Hits
More On This Day in Mob History
Further Reading — Mob History
Go deeper into the stories behind the dates. These are the essential books on organised crime history.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.


