10 Deadliest Members Of Murder Incorporated

Murder Incorporated; the name given by the media to the Mafia’s enforcement arm who operated between the 1930’s and 1940’s. Lepke Buchalter started the murder for hire group in 1933 with the mission to kill anyone for a profit, as long as that contract was approved by the National Crime Syndicate. With Murder Inc protecting him from rivals, helping him to keep police and judges on his payroll, Lepke was one of the highest ranking mobsters in his time, and that’s why he starts us off on our top 10 Deadliest Members of Murder Incorporated.

Louis “Lepke” Buchalter

Lepke trained as one of the “Gorilla Boys,” a gang of youngsters who worked as a farm team for mobsters in the area, he became the crucial figure in the Murder, Inc. story. Lepke would get orders from the syndicate, then pick the best hitman for the job, send off the contract, and wait for the task to be carried out.

In 1936 Joe Rosen, a candy store owner, was shot to death and Lepke was convicted on anti-trust charges. He skipped bail and disappeared in 1937, remaining underground until August 1939 when he surrendered. He was sent to Leavenworth prison and charged with Rosen’s murder. In March 1944, he was executed in the electric chair — the only major organised crime boss in American history ever put to death by the state.

Albert Anastasia

The Lord High Executioner was one of the most formidable characters in mob history, and was joint in command with Lepke during Murder Inc’s ten year spell. Unlike many other Murder Inc members who were indicted and charged with murders when Abe Reles turned mob informant, Albert Anastasia managed to successfully duck under the radar — mainly due to Reles being killed shortly before he was about to testify against him.

Anastasia would go out in true mob fashion in late 1957 when he was gunned down in a barber’s chair at the Park Sheraton Hotel on orders from Vito Genovese.

Jacob “Gurrah” Shapiro

Both Jacob Shapiro and Lepke Buchalter were partners, and initially Shapiro served as a mentor to Lepke. Shapiro was street smart, but lacked the vision and intelligence of Lepke. Together they made a good place for themselves in New York’s underworld, and became partners with future mob stars including Meyer Lansky and Lucky Luciano.

The role of Jacob Shapiro in Murder, Inc. was that of a recruiter and trainer for new recruits. He was never sentenced for a violent crime, but was imprisoned on charges of conspiracy and extortion, where he passed away due to a heart attack in 1947.

Emanuel “Mendy” Weiss

Weiss was one of Buchalter’s most trusted associates and became the second-in-command of Murder, Inc. In 1935, Charles Workman and Mendy entered the Palace Chop House where Workman shot Dutch Schultz in the washroom while Weiss dealt with men at the table. When a firefight broke out, Weiss fled leaving Workman behind. Workman complained bitterly — but as Weiss was too valuable, the getaway driver took the punishment instead. Weiss was later executed for the murder of Joseph Rosen.

Louis Capone

Louie Capone — no relation to Al Capone — was the third person executed for the murder of Rosen, alongside Buchalter and Weiss. He was the chief business manager and mediator of Murder, Inc., known as an unusually effective go-between for the organisation’s Italian and Jewish factions. He was not a trigger man — his role was operational and administrative — but he was convicted on the basis of senior organisational responsibility and died in the electric chair on 4 March 1944.

Frank “Dasher” Abbandando

Abbandando was a violent man — a psychopathic killer who picked up his nickname in jail, where he was held for beating a policeman, after displaying extraordinary skill and speed with a baseball bat. He used ice picks in most of the 30 murders he committed, as they didn’t make too much noise and left wounds that could be mistaken for natural causes. He was executed at Sing Sing in February 1942.

Abe “Kid Twist” Reles

Abe “Kid Twist” Reles was one of the organisation’s most dreaded gunmen — small in stature but a violent sociopath. He was an ice pick prodigy, allegedly capable of driving the instrument through a victim’s ear so precisely the wound was indistinguishable from a brain haemorrhage. He was the person who brought down the whole operation by becoming a government witness.

On 12 November 1941, just before he was due to testify against Albert Anastasia, he fell from the window of his room at the Half Moon Hotel and died. A 1951 grand jury ruled it accidental — but most historians believe he was thrown. The mob called him “the canary who could sing but couldn’t fly.”

Samuel “Red” Levine

Even prior to the formation of the Commission, Levine was a reliable trigger man, taking part in the murders of both chief bosses — Joe Masseria and Sal Maranzano. The removal of Masseria helped Lucky Luciano broker a peace agreement with Maranzano, whom he later also organised a hit on. Levine was one of the very few Murder, Inc. gunmen who evaded arrest entirely when the organisation collapsed.

Frankie Carbo

Frankie Carbo was one mobster who made the transition from Murder, Inc. member to made man in a New York family — the Lucchese organisation. He had five murder cases on his record but was never convicted of any. He is widely believed to have been instrumental in the murder of Benjamin “Bugsy” Siegel in 1947. After Murder Inc’s collapse, Carbo became the shadow power behind professional boxing for decades. He was eventually convicted of extortion in 1961, released due to poor health, and died in 1976.

Oscar “The Poet” Friedman

Oscar Friedman played an essential but unglamorous role — after a hitman completed a job, the getaway vehicle keys were handed to Oscar. He sold the cars to a junk dealer who stripped them completely and sold the parts, removing one of the most consistent forensic threads available to investigators. He later turned informant, disclosing the junkyard where parts from numerous Murder Inc crime vehicles could be found. After his release from jail, he was never heard from again.

Frequently Asked Questions